and her campaign manager, patti doyle, went to -- during the campaign, her campaign against president obama, fought very hard, and you can go look it up and you can check it out and if you look at cnn this past week, patti doyle was on "wolf blitzer" saying that this happened. blumenthal sent

out and if you look at cnn this past week, patti doyle was on wolf blitzer saying that this happened. >> not exactly. this is misleading. what patti doyle said on cnn was neither the campaign nor hillary clinton herself started the birther movement, but she did confirm that a volunteer coordinator did forward in the e-mail that promoted the hillary made the decision to let that person go immediately. the pivotal word here is forward. if the person forwarded this early birther conspiracy e- mail, they inherently are not the original author which does not support the case donald trump is trying to make on the stage which he doubled down on saying clinton started this and he finished it by pressuring president obama to put out his long form birth certificate. he didn't put out any explanation as to why he continued the birther theory this year you can find a lot more right now on 9news.com. >> thank you, brandon. our political experiments kelly mayer and ian selvari join us at 9:00 and now this debate will influence the next one and how lester holt did as tonight's moderator. the undeci

fought very hard, you can go look it up and you can check it out, and if you week, at cnn this past patty doyle was on wolf blitzer that this happened, sent mcclathchy, a highly respected president, to question the president very hard about it, she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved, i didn't

hard, and you can go look it up and you can check it out and if you look at cnn this past week, patti doyle was on "wolf blitzer" saying that this happened. blumenthal sent mcclatchy, highly respected reporter, to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it very hard. she failed to get the birth certificate.

cnn this past week, patti doyle was on wolf blitzer saying that this happened. >> not exactly. this is misleading. what patti doyle said on cnn was neither the campaign nor hillary clinton herself started the birther movement, but she did confirm that a volunteer coordinator did forward e-mail that promoted the birther conspiracy. hillary made the decision to let that person go immediately. the pivotal word here is forward. if the person forwarded this early birther conspiracy e- mail, they inherently are not the original author which does not support the case donald trump is trying to make on the stage which he doubled down on saying clinton started this and he finished it by pressuring president obama to put out his explanation as to why he continued the birther theory this year while saying he laid it to rest in 2011. you can find a lot more right now on 9news.com. >> thank you, brandon. our political experiments kelly mayer and ian selvari join us at 9:00 and now this debate will influence the next one and how lester holt did as tonight's moderator. >>> who won tonight as f

and her campaign manager, patti doyle, went to -- during the campaign, her campaign against president obama, fought very hard, and you can go look it up and you can check it out and if

and if you look at cnn this past week, patty doyle was on wolf blitzer, saying that this happened. blumenthal sent mcklatchy, highly respected reporter to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it very hard. she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved, i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate. so i'm satisfied with it, and i'll tell you why i'm satisfied with it, because i want to get on to defeating isis. because i want to get on to creating jobs. because i want to get on to having a strong border. because i want to get on to things that are very important to me, and that are very important to the country. >> i'll let you respond, it's important, but i just want to get the answer here. the birth certificate was produced in 2011. you continued to tell the story and question the president's legitimacy in 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, as recently as january. so the question is, what changed your mind? >> well, nobody was pressing it. nobody was caring much about it. i figured you'd ask the question tonight of course, but nobody was caring much about i

and her campaign manager, patty doyle went to -- during the campaign, her campaign against president obama fought very hard, and you can go look it up, and you can check it out. if you look at cnn, this past week, patty sole's doyle, was on wolf blitzer saying this happened, blumenthal sent mcclatchey to kenya to find out about it, they were pressing it very hard. she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved, i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate. >> just listen to what you heard. and clearly as donald just admitted he knew he was going to stand on this debate stage, and lester holt was going to be asking us questions, he tried to put the whole racist birther lie to bed. but it can't be dismissed that easi easily. he has really started his political activity based on this racist lie that our first black president was not an american citizen. >> i feel like woody allen in annie hall, well, i happen to have marshall right here. i happen to have patty doyle right here. >> yes. >> is that what you said on cnn zm. >> no, it is absurd, it is absurd what don

i happen to have patty doyle right here. is that what you said on cnn? >> no. it is absurd. it is absurd what donald trump just said. i never sent anyone to kenya. >> what he said, there was a staffer, not sure whether she was paid or not. >> here's what happened. there was a volunteer in late '07. >> volunteer on the clinton campaign. >> on the clinton campaign who forwarded an e-mail about obama's heritage saying she was a muslim. we found out about it. i fired him. i called you david fluff and apologized. >> from the obama campaign. >> his campaign manager because we didn't want to run that kind of campaign. that's called shutting it down, ladies and gentlemen. that's not called trafficking in or promoting it or perpetuating it. that's called shutting it down. >> there was an allegation from someone from mclatchy that bloomenthal promoted this story to mclatchy. >> sydney denied that and sydney never worked for our campaign. >> van, what did you think? then we'll go to the trump supporters. >> let's not get too excited. we have said on many nights donald trump has destroy

her campaign manager, patty doyle, went during the campaign, her campaign against president obama, fought very hard. you can go look it up and you can check it out and if you look at cnn this past week, patty was on wolf blitzer blumenthal said mcclatchy, highly respected reporter, to kenya to find out she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate.>> that is false. there is no clinton -- evidence this. they had no ties to either candidate or her staff. after lester holt pressed trump on why he had released his tax return, clinton weighed in that trump must be hiding something. >> you've got to ask yourself, why won't he releases tax returns or maybe he doesn't want the american people, all of you watching tonight, to know that he has paid nothing in federal taxes. you didn't pay any federal smart.>> that means zero for troops, zero for vets.>> that isn't totally false, but she has a few points wrong. clinton has one thing correct. records indicate there were two years in the '70s paid nothing in income taxes. she ignore

and her campaign manager, patty doyle went to her campaign against president obama, fought very hard and you can go look it up, you can check it out, if you look at cnn this past week, patty doyle was on wolf blitzer, saying that this respected reporter to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it very hardr she failed to get the birth certificate. when in got involved i didn't fail.wh i got him to give the birth certificate. so, i'm satisfied with it.it i'll tell you why i'm satisfied with it -- >> that was a -- because i want to get on to defeating isis, to get on to create jobs, to get on to having strong border.st because i want to get on to things that are very importantry to me and that are very important to the country. >>to i'll let you respond. it's important.s i just want to get the answer here. birth certificate was producede in 2011 you continued to telll the story and question the president's legitimacy in 2012, '13, '14, '15 as recently as january. the questi

and if you look at cnn this past week, patty doyle was on wolf blitzer, saying that this happened. blumenthal sent mcklatchy, highly respected reporter to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it very hard. she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved, i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate. so i'm satisfied with it, and i'll tell you why i'm satisfied with it, because i want to get on to defeating isis. because i want to get on to creating jobs. because i want to get on to

of course, even patty doyle, hillary clinton's campaign manager in 2008 until she was fired by hillary clinton, admitted on friday to wolf blitzer that she said, "yeah," these are her words, "there was a volunteer in iowa who was pushing this." so this started with hillary clinton's campaign, number one. number the work it was trump who put the issue to rest when he got president obama to release his birth certificate years later. and number three, he said that president obama was born in this country, period, and let's move on to creating jobs, defeating radical islam, rebuilding our inner cities. >> dickerson: the reason i want to stick on this a little bit is he promoted this for five years. so this isn't some passing notion. this is a considerable amount of energy and time and money that say anything about his citizenship. also, if you look at the clinton campaign, they fired the one staffer who sent an e-mail about this immediately. donald trump spent five years, his own money, called press conferences to promote this idea. so i go back to my original question, why did he change h

let's get reaction from patti doyle, hillary clinton's presidential campaign manager back in 2007 andhanks for joining us. >> thanks so much for having me, wolf. >> all right. just tweeted a couple tweets. let me put them up on the screen. hillary clinton or her '08 campaign did not start birther movement, period. i was there. then another tweet. i fired the rogue and i called david plouffe to apologize for said rogue. what does that mean? someone supporting hillary clinton was trying to promote this so-called birther issue? what happened? >> so absolutely the campaign nor hillary did not start the birther movement, period, end of the story there. there was a volunteer coordinator, i believe in late 2007, i think in december, one of our volunteer coordinators in one of the counties in iowa. i don't recall whether they an actual paid staffer, but they did forward an e-mail that promoted the conspiracy. >> the birther conspiracy? >> yeah. hillary made the decision immediately to let that person go. we let that person go. and it was so, you know, beyond the pale, wolf, and so not worthy

look at cnn this past week, patty doyle was on wolf blitzer, saying that this respected reporter to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it very hardr she failed to get the birth certificate. when in got involved i didn't fail.wh i got him to give the birth certificate. so, i'm satisfied with it.it i'll tell you why i'm satisfied with it -- >> that was a -- because i want to get on to defeating isis, to get on to create jobs, to get on to having strong border.st because i want to get on to things that are very importantry to me and that are very important to the country. >>to i'll let you respond. it's important.s i just want to get the answer here. birth certificate was producede in 2011 you continued to telll the story and question the president's legitimacy in 2012, '13, '14, '15 as recently as january. the question is, what changed your mind? >> nobody wast pressing it. nobody was tear -- caring much i figured you'd ask the questionn tonight, of course. but nobody was caring much about it. but i was the one that got him to produce the birth certificate. and i think i did a g

and if you look at cnn this past week, patty doyle was on wolf blitzer saying this happened. blumenthal sent a highly respected reporter to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it very hard. she failed to get a birth certificate. when i got involved, i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate so i'm satisfied with it. defeatingget onto isis, creating jobs, to having a strong border. i want to get onto things that are important to me and are very important to the country. theer: i just want to get answer here. the birth certificate was produced in 2011 and you continued to question the president's legitimacy and two thousand 12, 2013, 2014, 2015, as recently as january. mr. trump: no one was pressing it. i figured you would ask the question but no one was caring much about it. i was the one who got him to produce the birth certificate and i think i did a good job. secretary clinton also fought it. true.ody says that's not it's true. sidney blumenthal said the reporter. you have to take a look at cnn last week, the interview. she was involved. just like sh

and patty doyle, the former campaign director for hillary clinton's 2008 presidential bid.john, the fbi director yesterday said the clinton e-mail pace was not a cliffhanger and critics who say his investigation is partisan is, quote, full of baloney. so why this hearing on capitol hill? >> it's not a cliffhanger because he released all this information on friday of labor day weekend when everyone was at a barbecue and not paying attention to politics. look, we have seen various portions of the executive branch in the bms administration been politicized. we had class action lawsuit targeting conservative groups it the fbi has been criticized not just by people in the media on the right side of it isth the a by former fbi agents. saying they're out there doing the bidding of hillary clinton and the democratic party -- >> but people -- >> -- the eye of skepticism. >> does it matter that the fbi director is a republican? >> look, you don't look at the guy's party affiliation, you look at his actions. the the guy certainly had a stellar reputation up until this point. but i lis

and her campaign manager, patti doyle, went to -- during the campaign, her campaign against presidentma, fought very hard. and you can go look it up, and you can check it out. and if you look at cnn this past week, patti solis doyle was on wolf blitzer saying that this happened. blumenthal sent mcclatchy, highly respected reporter at mcclatchy, to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it very hard. she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved, i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate. so i'm satisfied with it. and i'll tell you why i'm satisfied with it. mr. holt: that was -- mr. trump: because i want to get on to defeating isis, because i want to get on to creating jobs, because i want to get on to having a strong border, because i want to get on to things that are very important to me and that are very important to the country. >> i will let you respond. it's important. but i just want to get the answer here. the birth certificate was produced in 2011. you've continued to tell the story and question the president's legitimacy in 2012, 2013, 201

and you can go look it up and you can check it out, and it you look at cnn this past week, patty solace doyleas on wolf blitzer saying this happened. blumenthal sent mcclatchy, highly respected reporter to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it hard. she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved, i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate. so i'm satisfied with it, and i'll tell you why i'm satisfied with it, because i want to get onto defeating isis, i want to get onto creating jobs, because i want to get onto having a strong border, i want to get onto things that are important to me and important to the country. moderator: i'll let you respond that it is important, the answer here, the birth certificate was produced in 2011, you continued to tell the story and queson

>> you bought it when patty doyle came in. anytime somebody sells dominoes, and then you don't have to worry if the pizza comes with no cheese or banana peppers. eat the pizza, drink the beers. i don't care if there's an activist knocking on the door, i say sidelines. find out what a ceo reveals about a tough quarter. and maybe you heard september can be unkind to the stock markets. i'll reveal the reality. the lightning round. bring your best questions and stick with cramer. you're choosing more complete allergy relief and all the enjoyment that comes along with it. when we breathe in allergens, our bodies react by overproducing 6 key inflammatory substances. most allergy pills only control 1. more complete relief means enjoyment of every beautiful moment. flonase, six is greater than one, changes everything. ? mr. clean gets tough on dirt and grime and grease in just a minute mr. clean will clean your whole house and every room that's in it floors, doors, walls, halls he's so tough, he cleans 'em all mr. clean! let's feed hi

hillary clinton's presidential campaign was run by patty doyle. >> you do row go calls. john: they even advertise in the mes sky. arena is bigger than the crowd it looks bad. >> the football stadium seats 80,000 people, the only problem, romney had 1,000 people in thehe crowd making the whole event look like a flop. >> we are painting part of the backdrop for the shot that you see from the ricer. john: campaigns obsess about every sign, every camera angle. >> you have to see the campaign through the lens of the camera. >> we'll set them up on ricers and make sure the angles are right. the signs are always in the perfect position for television cameras. >> we have something like-foot 40-50-foot banners to cover t banners.eo john: what difference does it make?? >> visual matters so much. campaigns come down to photographs and photography. cameras need light and sounds. >> ladies and gentlemen, please welcome the next president of the united states. >> >> if we fail, the message stays here with 2,000 or 3,000 people in ohio. the goal is to make sure it translates to as many

and her campaign manager, patty doyle went to -- during the campaign, her campaign against president obama fought very hard, and you can go look it up and you can check it out. if you look at cnn this past week, patty doyle was on wolf blitzer saying that this happened, blumenthal sent mcclatchey to kenya to find out about it, they were pressing very hard. they failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved i didn't fail, i got him to give the birth certificate. i'm satisfied with it. i want to get on to defeating isis, to creating jobs. i want to get on to having a strong boarder. i want to get on to things that are very important to me, and that are very important to the country. >> i will let you reresponded, it's important. i want to get the answer here. the birth certificate was produced in 2011, you continued to tell the story and question the president's legitimacy in 2012, '13, '14 as recently as january. >> nobody was pressing it, nobody was caring much about it. i figured you'd ask the question tonight, of course. i was the one that got him to produce the birth ce

if you look at cnn this past week, patty doyle was on wolf blitzer saying that this hammond. blumenthal sent mcclatchey, a highly respected reporter at mcclatchey to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it very hard. she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved, i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate. so i'm satisfied with it. i'll tell you why i'm satisfied with it, because i want to get on to defeating isis. because i want to get on to creating jobs. because i want to get on to having a strong border. because i want to get on to things that are very important to me and that are very important to the country. >> i'll let you respond, it's important, i just want to get the answer here the birth certificate was produced in 2011, you continued to tell the story and question the president's legitimacy in 2012, '13, '14, '15, as recently as january. so the question is what changed your mind? >> nobody was pressing it. nobody was caring much about it. i figured you'd ask the question tonight, of course. nobody was caring much about it. i w

sydney bloombloomenthal, very c friend of secretary clinton, and her campaign manager, patty doyle, went to, during the campaign, her campaign against president obama, fought very hard and you can go look it up and you can check it out and if patty doyle was on wolf blitzer, saying that this happened, sent a highly respected reporter to kenya to find out about it, they were pressing it very hard. she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved, i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate. i'm satisfied with it. and i'll tell you why -- >> that was in 2011. isis. i want to get onto creating jobs. because i want to get onto having a strong border. because i want to get onto things that are very important to me and that are very important to the country. >> i will let you respond, it's important, but i want to get the answer here. the birth certificate was produced in 2011. you continued to tell the story and question the president's legitimate si in 2012, '13, '14, as recently as january. so, the question is, what nobody was caring much about it. i figured you would

and her campaign manager, patty doyle, went to, during the campaign, her campaign against president obama, fought very hard, and you can go look it up and check it out, and if you look at cnn this past week patty doyle was on wolf blitzer saying that this happened. blumenthal sent a highly respected reporter to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it very hard. she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved, i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate. i'm satisfied with it. i'll tell you why i'm satisfied with it. because i want to get on to defeating isis. i because i want to get on to creating jobs. because i want to get on to having a strong border. because i want to get on with things that are important to me and to the country. >> i just want to question the answer here. the birth certificate was produced in 2011. you continued to tell the story and question the president's legit ma say in 2012, '13, '14, '15. the question is what changed your mind. >> nobody was pressing it, nobody cared much about it. i figured you would ask the question but nobo

and her campaign manager patti doyle, went to, during the campaign, her campaign against president obama, fought very hard and you can go look it up patti solis doyle was on "wolf blitzer" saying that this happened. blumenthal sent mcclatchy, highly respected reporter at mcclampy, to kenya to find out about it. they were pressing it very hard. she failed to get the birth certificate. when i got involved i didn't fail. i got him to give the birth certificate. so i'm satisfied with it, and i'll tel >> that was in 2011. >> i want to get on to defeating isis, to creating jobs, because i want to get on to having a strong border, because i want to get on to things that are very important to me, and that are very important to the country. >> i will let you respond. it's important. i just want to get the answer here. the birth certificate was produced in 2011. you continued to tell the story and question the president's legitimacy in 2012, '13, '14, '15, as recently as january. your mind? >> nobody was pressing it, caring much about it, i figured you'd ask the question tonight of course. nobody

. >> by the way, an issue that patty doyle in 2008 admitted was an issue that mrs.linton injected into her campaign in 2008 in a quiet but direct way against then senator obama. >> just as a point of fact again, donald trump did not accept when barack obama released his birth certificate and kept this until friday that's five years. we only have a little time left so i want to ask you -- >> that's just not true that he kept it up for five years. it's simply not true. >> it is true. >> it wasn't like he was talking about it on a regular basis until then. >> he's wrong. donald trump has talked about this continuously for the last five years. it's not true that he dropped it. it's not true that he walked back from it. every time he was asked about it, he raised it. >> john heilemann? >> i agree with katty. the notion that trump from the moment he obtained the birth certificate -- to begin with, from the start of the rumor through to the provision of the long form birth certificate was an outrageous racist -- it's not like -- donald trump tried to claim credit for putti