jd vance writes that he was an extreme exception.obody else in his community made it out of poor kentucky, ohio. host: what kind of student was he? prof. chua: excellent. not only incredibly bright but curious, open-minded, willing to argue but in a nice way. he would always reach out to the of theof the opposite political spectrum. he is an open republican, one of and everybodyyale loved him because he was willing to talk to people. host: what do your students think of our president? prof. chua: yale law school is not a fan. that is where hillary clinton were -- went to school. yale law school is extremely progressive and we have many clinics that are bringing lawsuits, many of them incredibly important standing up for the rule of law. people can disagree about the merits, but we always want to make sure that the rule of the is in place. i think they have done a magnificent job. the judiciary is such an important institution here. as long as we still have our separation of powers and three branches of government, you might disagree

jeff bennett, danny zavala, joyce vance and jeremy bass. my belated thanks to bill kristol for joining us and having an opinion there. dan, i'm going to begin with you here in new york. i've used the expression change of venue in a different context at the top of the broadcast. in a way this is a form of that i guess. what just happened today, why are they trying to move the court jurisdiction where this is going to be heard? >> this is a classic defense maneuver. i've removed cases, attorneys who have had them in federal court have removed cases and a law which allows defendants from different states and you have enough dollar amount and controversy, that's why there were so many millions alleged in this. if you have enough involved a defendant can drag it out of state court and up to federal court. it's automatic. this is not a motion, this is not a request. once a defendant files this notice of removal the case is now in federal court and it's incumbent upon the plaintiff to get it back down to state court, which is not an easy thing to

attorney joyce vance who always keeps all of us honest. michael schmidt, let me start with you. first, your reporting on this attorney who was in the white house, in the oval office, meeting with the president, story the white house tried to cloud up a little bit after the fact. who was he and what is the significance? >> well, the sort of first phase of this investigation is coming to an end and that was the one led by ty cobb. that was the production of documents setting up of interviews between white house officials and the special counsel. most of that has been completed, so the president now has to prepare for whatever the next phase is. that is obviously the interview and then if mueller decides to do anything. and there is a sense in the white house that the president needs a really experienced person that knows what these things could look like to be in place. and a lot of people think emmet flood is that person. he's someone that represented vice-president cheney, as you mentioned he did represent clinton during impeachment. he is a veteran washington lawyer with a lot

was only markham can put together a short film from vance to his computer games the us filmmaker combined multiple genres to create an atmospheric story of plenty. of leg lifts it's not an easy feat for the plant. live. those who successfully rise to the challenges and make it to the end will gain salvation and a new game. next week. to visit more more frequently turning to social media sources to prove human rights violations and what is actually happening in the footage digital detectives go on a search for the truth following close on the internet thanks to each on shift. in. europe. what unites. them what divides. the. present. what binds the continent together lenses and stories aplenty the. spotlight on people's. lives on the w. kitchens. into her home. in general max series is a very simple recipe but it's what made like. fifty international dishes. the recipes for cooking the dishes to come in. the kitchen the city. the romance in sixty minutes long d.w. . with different languages we fight for different things that's fine but let me also make up for freedom freedom of speech and f

was malcolm com put together a short film from vance to use computer games the us film maker combined multiple genres to create an atmospheric story. play. live it's not an easy feat for the plan. live. those who successfully rise to the challenges and make it to the end will gain salvation and in a new game. next week. to visit more more frequently turning to social media sources to prove human rights violations and what is actually happening in the footage digital detectives go on a search for the truth following close on the internet thanks very much on shift. just stretching the flames. let's keep the clintons it's time some time talents. lose its credibility charm the frontrunner. could end up sitting on a surplus of explosives to. gain trade goods come visit me concerning thirty minutes on the phone. with different languages we fight for different things that's fine but we all stick up for freedom freedom of speech and freedom of press. giving freedom of choice global news that matters w. made for minds. it's all happening. the fifth fleet cut your link to news from africa and t

couple of hours next to them in the police station the i'm right alexander so as you're saying they vance are unfolding rather quickly and as you've mentioned put it on what has now been moved to what can we expect will happen to him now. well he is brought to. as we learn now or perhaps also to kele we don't know exactly but what we know is because it was a european ones he has to bring two to just just just and well and it's not absolutely clear if it's today or it will be each tomorrow because it takes a couple of hours to organize everything so the ex could be tomorrow on the try could be tomorrow and the decision for the expertise issue is coming up for tomorrow or the day after tomorrow perhaps as we know it so far alexandra drexel joining us from should be thank you. i'm not joined by a correspondent. actually been covering this story for a while now thanks for joining us so you know we've just heard from alexander that they vent some moving quickly but you all could possibly be at the state prosecutor's office what would happen if he is handed over to spanish authorities well firs

david vance brand of political film is quite different. like the spread of freedom and i don't make films that are just comedy but i think especially with serious topics humor is important and helps to make things bearable their control it does consequently just get dark it's probably not a spot on the ministerial me. after all and sometimes. it's a pretty hands on causing comedy one of the best in recent years for times to monday funday cutter to showcase. the present informed by the past more diverse than ever face to face with german films a portrait of a generation that mirrors the new germany german film has never been this international. and that's it for this keynote special edition on german film more on the face to face thought it says and all the german film prize nominees online join us next time till then go easy on the pope go. for dream go international talk show for journalists discuss the topic of the week always in english the former russian spy second script problem has triggered a major crisis between the west. there's e

attorney joyce vance who spent 25 years as a federal prosecutor. jill, i'd like to begin with you, there's a term of art at the white house. something called the in town travel pool. you have the glory and honor of riding many vehicles behind the president to go where they are going this evening. he went to a donor's home in virginia for a closed media event. you're among the few that saw him out of the vehicle and walking, correct? >> that's right. >> this is the only appearance we've seen at all. i mean a photographer with a long lens manage to capture an image of him with an umbrella, capturing him walking from the white house to a limo. the president has had no events on his public schedule. we haven't been able to ask him questions we couldn't ask him yesterday, today. this is very unusual for the president. he's someone who typically interacts with reporters, we've seen him completely silent on this topic on twitter. usually trump's advisers are begging him to stop tweeting about issues, the russia investigation being the first and foremost s

for more i turn to joyce vance, a former federal prosecutor from alabama. thanks for being here tonight. >> thanks for having me, ari. >> when we know that don mcgahn has to play more than one role, he has the duty to the commander in chief and give him advice in that role, but also has a legal duty to comply with the special counsel probe, what do you see in this story that you think don mcgahn is likely to provide to mueller? >> it's an interesting question. mcgahn has the duty of candor in response to mueller. so in response to questions that are posed to him, he must be truthful, like anyone else, he testifies in front of a grand jury. but that prohibition against not being fully truthful means a little bit more to lawyer whose are officers of the court. so mcgahn obviously has a lot of insight into his conversations with the president, and as we've learned tonight from this story, the president is prone to talk to witnesses. something his lawyers have undoubtedly advised him against doing. where this could become a crime, there's a narrow species of ob

>> reporter: that's what we're hearing from investigator richard vance.urvivor of this crash. he was the pilot. that's what he told investigators. 14 members of the ntsb are on their way here to try and determine what brought down this liberty helicopter shortly after 7:00 eastern time killing all five passengers on board. >> my name is mayday, mayday. >> reporter: the desperate pilot of this helicopter sending a frantic mayday call after losing altitude over east river. >> say it one more time. >> engine failure over the east river. >> reporter: amateur video capturing the helicopter plunging into the freezing river, then tipping over and taking on water. >> there were six people in the helicopter. the pilot freed himself, the other five did not. >> and he was like asking for help. >> reporter: tug boats rapidly arriving on the scene. emergency responders working desperately to rescued the trap passengers. >> the five people besides the pilot were all tightly harnessed so these harnesses had to be cut and removed in order to get these folks off of this h

joyce vance, enjoy your weekend. elise jordan, i'll see you tomorrow morning on "today." >>> more fallout. more fallout for a fox news host after comments she made about a parkland shooting survivor. the latest companies that are pulling their ads from laura ingraham's show. >>> also stormy daniels isn't going away but new numbers show her story doesn't seem to be changing the hearts and minds of the president's supporters. so why are so many evangelicals turning the other cheek? have a higher risk of stroke due to afib, a type of irregular heartbeat not caused by a heart valve problem. but no matter where i ride, i go for my best. so if there's something better than warfarin, i'll go for that too. eliquis. eliquis reduced the risk of stroke better than warfarin, plus had less major bleeding than warfarin. eliquis had both. don't stop taking eliquis unless your doctor tells you to, as stopping increases your risk of having a stroke. eliquis can cause serious and in rare cases fatal bleeding. don't take eliquis if you

attorney and now an msnbc contributor joyce vance. i want to talk about the mueller subpoena of the trump organization. i think the surprise here is that it was a subpoena and not a request for documents. do you assume -- a request was made and denied and that is why -- what was your reaction to the subpoena aspect of this? >> i think we have to be careful not to make assumptions here but something that we've heard from the trump organization over time is that they were in a cooperative posture with the mueller investigation and sharing documents that were needed. so this news that there is now a subpoena that the subpoena was issued some weeks ago is definitely a different trend. and does it signify anything? it may just be mueller trying to cut square corners. but far more likely it indicates that they need a document of legal significance that offers them teeth. and whether that is because cooperation was faltering or because they were not receiving documents that they expected would be in the company's possession, but we'll learn

basically quite unfounded but still very useful impression that situation is not that bad because vance sygate all last year there have been agreed deal of seagulls coming from washington is that people in the around president from i c b s about a military operation and military operation ease highly likely to scully into a major war so it might be a false impression it might be a lie but it's still a useful life what is this going to look like to the other countries the neighboring countries around the careers in asia or japan for example japan has a significant role to play in the security of the region. pennies are not happy about this context because he correctly see it as waste of time and probably sums of ways to get around the international sanctions vance again as you've been also has relatively little influence maybe more than sounds good here but still very little influence on these developments. and everybody else every all as a neighbor say china and russia feel a great deal of relief because pretty much everybody who has a knowledge of situation understands that talks this

i turn now to former federal prosecutor joyce vance and jessica chambers. how important is it that some of this witness discussion relates to the potential removal of bob mueller himself? >> it's bad, ari, not just in the legal sense, not just in the sense that there are people who will face criminal charges as the mueller investigation moves forward, it's also bad for our institutions. we expect the president to have respect for the foundational institutions like the justice department, that are part of our democracy. and here we have the president of the united states flouting the norms that protect those agencies, clearly trying to influence practices and policies, and whether it rises to the level of actually trying to inappropriately influence a witness or trying to interfere and obstruct an investigation, what he has done over the last year to weaken those institutions, in order to protect himself and his friends is devastating, it's hard work that we'll have to do to climb back up that hill when this administration ends. >> and joyce, i don't know if

the bottom panel shows the vance --line study daily advances abigail, how is looking? abigail: looking bearish. bonds trading lower and now we are looking at declines once again for the major averages. not so long ago, the nasdaq was down 1%, solar weekly basis, we are looking at very big declines. .3% awayq was about from being the weekly decline back on february 9, but that is what we are looking up, selling akin to what we had back in february and if we happen to the bloomberg, let's take a look at the intraday chart on the s&p 500. look at the intraday chart of the s&p 500, we can see that selling action. from a sector standpoint, this is what we are looking at. in the eleven o'clock hour, a look at the imax. all the sectors were green and now that almost all of them are red. sectors, look at the declines, 1.6% for the financial sector with tech down more than 1%. a real reversal here. good points just how tightly wound these markets are. let's take a look at this reversal with an intraday chart of the s&p 500. decent gains in the morning and then a sudden leg lowe

attorney now an msnbc contributor joyce vance. hi, all. matt apuzzo, let me start with you. >>> these officials said that plainly it is common practice for lawyers -- i think anyone that is covering the special counsel probe knows that reince priebus and steve bannon and don mcgahn all share an attorney and that was permitted by the special counsel, but that there was a conflict, that the white house acknowledged a conflict between the spouse of mark corallo's attorney and donald trump. seems like a big flashing red light. >> that's right. it is 100% the case that, as you mention, this is essentially about the representation of mark corallo. in the legal world it's known as divergent interests. the president and mark corallo have divergent interests. he has accused the trump administration of attempting to obstruct justice and so you can't as a lawyer both carry water for that argument and carry the water that, no, the president is not obstructing justice. what is fascinating to me is that this was obvious to every reporter and every lawye

s is in his brownie and sight it's nice and airy partly thanks to air vance borrowed from the s. class turning up the heat makes them glow red turning it down they glow blue it's a fun detail just like the massage seats in the steering wheel from the esquire one . leg also. the c.e.o.'s coupe a sumptuous interior continues the flowing contours of the exterior a choice of high quality materials reinforces the upscale feel. the ambient lighting systems choice of sixty four colors invokes something of the modern lounge atmosphere. the air jets are meant to recall jet engines. noise that's right no says the c.e.o.'s is and it's new asst and back now the rear seat accommodates not just two with three passengers so a total of five people to go along. aside from the red and blue glowing air vents the digital displays have also been spiffed up here and there now they appear in different colors depending on the drive mode. the one profile has been demanded to many sacrifices on the impracticality front the rear seat can be folded down in three sections. as far as right hole is concerned t

pilot richard vance told police a strap from a passenger's bag may have accidentally wrapped around and pulled an emergency fuel cutoff lever like this. the tourists trapped in harnesses similar to these as the chopper turned over and sank. eric adam snapped this photo of the liberty chopper. he was in the same pre-flight safety briefing before leaving in a differ chopper. >> first, you have to extract yourself from the tether, and then you have to get yourself out of the seat belt. where is that buckle? in front of you? to the left, to the right? those are all things that would not have been easy to figure out in a chaotic crash situation. >> all of a sudden because of the dark and because of the disorientation, people don't know how to open up the seat belt. >> reporter: tonight, 14 ntsb investigators are on the scene. >> there were harnesses. we'll be looking at this helicopter to see whether the harnesses were functioning and whether the passengers were using them. >> reporter: investigators are also looking into whether the doors on the chopper were open to allow for better photogr

and vance payments are uncommon and print runs are secret there are neither wholesalers nor such a thing as book price fixing. the market is small and dominated by international bestsellers translations of which don't pay much. many bookshops also sell wine gift items and t. to make ends meet. some booksellers had reservations about stocking cuts only mitchell yaks novel. not because it's badly written but because it takes on a national taboo. in june one nine hundred forty one romanian troops massacred the jewish population of the city of yauch program. more than ten thousand people were killed to this day many remain ians refused to recognize their country's role in the holocaust. and i feel racial hatred is undermining humanity for us what saddens me in particular is this. i said in one interview that the goal of my book is to help create a better world among my readers. out there as a thought and that was singled out for ridicule by numerous hostile media outlets when i meet the video. today only four thousand jews live in romania it seems only a matter of time before jewish life her

up, ben laidler of hsbc securities and kathleen gaffney of eaton vance.omberg. ♪ mom, dad, can we talk? sure. what's up, son? i can't be your it guy anymore. what? you guys have xfinity. you can do this. what's a good wifi password, mom? you still have to visit us. i will. no. make that the password: "you_stillóhave_toóvisit_us." that's a good one. seems a bit long, but okay... set a memorable wifi password with xfinity my account. one more way comcast is working to fit into your life, not the other way around. takes on terrorist. some support tariffs, some don't. markets don't care. goldilocks strikes back. markets are at an important crossroads. china ties its fate to one man. >> welcome to bloomberg. >> the word you have to note the goldilocks. s&p futures up by seven. the euro -- the dollar goes pretty much nowhere. when everyone is going to be watching is what is going on with the 10 year yield. tons of supply coming out, particularly today. it could be dicey. 2.5%we be breaching that level? longer,lly slower for china economy. what does that do? wha

to bring in matt miller, former sparm for attorney general holder, msnbc analyst as well as joyce vance, and joyce, when you hear this and you hear the lawyers fighting and you see the lie detector come out, what is your view of the wider significance? >> lie detector tests are really interesting, ari. you've noted that they're not admissible in court, and that's because their scientific validity hasn't been established yet. not to say it couldn't be done in the future. and perhaps this would be the case. but lie detector tests are widely used in law enforcement. particularly early on in cases when people are trying to decide whether a witness is telling the truth. also, widely used in the justice department as an employment device. so the introduction of this lie detector test not as evidence, but as an indication that ms. daniels is being truthful at least in so far as her story about having intercourse with the president is very compelling here. >> and matt miller, when you were serving the obama administration, i don't recall him making a joinder motion for any lawsuits like this. >

joyce vance, law professor at george washington university. jonathan turley and new york times reporter michael schmidt who had another big scoop. >> what's new. >> he'sincredible. >> mike, we could talk about so much right now, but first let's talk about day five of the president. i guess it's day five. maybe even more than that, that this stormy daniels news has frozen the president of the united states yet again. this is yet to happen. i know i was critical of the legal techniques stormy daniels' lawyer was taking but if you look at it through the -- through the lens of politics, my gosh, this guy has done to donald trump and stormy daniels as done to donald trump what donald trump was able to do to people like marco rubio and jeb bush and other political giants for a year and a half and that is freeze them, tongue tie them and get them trying to fig dwrur out, how do i respond to this because he has no response and he's hiding. >> you have that exactly right, joe. the lawyer for stormy daniels is doing to the president of the united states

>> casey. >> vance. >> and debby. birthplace of buddy holly and texas tech. general january i like it. go to the maps. show you the potential of nor'easter moving across the atlantic. coming off the coast. we think this is the new england event. there are your storm watches and warnings. certainly overnight tonight and tomorrow. that's what we are going to be watching. thank you, texas for coming. wave to everyone at home we love you, lubbock, texas. steve, ainsley and brian back to you. steve: not just the weather but a lesson in lubbock. brian: all things good in texas. 18 minutes before the top of the hour. still ahead, in god we trust back in our schools. details coming up straight ahead. ainsley: plus the left leaning media calling to get rid of ice. is this really what the democrats are going to run on in 2020? we will debate that next ♪ i was stressed out ♪ turn up your swagger game with one a day men's. ♪ get ready for the wild life a complete multivitamin with key nutrients, plus b vitamins for heart health.

frank montoya is a former special agent and joyce vance. thank you all for joining me tonight. what do you make of this? why is the president attacking mueller by name now? it's personal. it's just about destroying this guy. he doesn't have a legal case. that why he is doing it? >> it's absolutely a shift going on. and the new lawyer he has brought on to his legal team is a fighter who is pulling no punches, who believe there's is a conspiracy in the fbi to go after the president. >> says he believes. >> yes, says he believes. this is just the beginning. >> joe di geneva. >> in '92 he worked on the passport scandal. >> he is bulking up. it looks to me like he is getting personal, however, natasha. he wants to destroy. tell me about this. >> it really makes no sense. the white house kind of had a victory when it managed to get mueller's team to submit written questions or at least topics to the white house about a possible sit-down interview with the president. >> interview. where does that word come from? help me with that word. questioning, interrogation. why it is an intervie

the unabomber, certainly a very solitary person, very capable, deadly, going to the killer ofjudge vanceombers, other bombings in georgia. and in the florida area. to eric robert rudolph, the centennial park bomber who also bombed an abortion provider in alabama. these folks tend to work by themselves. you don't tend to see teams of bombers, people working in concert. so it remains to be seen. maybe there are other people, and of course that is what the appeal is through the media by the law enforcement now, for the public to come out and help. so if you are running this case, what are the clues that you are looking at? well, first, there are a couple different channels going on right now. one is the forensics of the devices that they can recover and the post—blast investigation. that is very detailed examination of anything that came out of the already exploded devices. they are looking for dna, they are looking for fingerprints, they are looking for essentially the bomber‘s signature. what type of initiation, what were the explosive components how is it constructed, what was the shrapn

. >> reporter: mark vance is losing ground as mud flows in. >> we're a little scared that something big's going to come down. >> reporter: tonight another blast of dangerous weather and rain is blowing in. threat of more mud slides and flooding comes as rescues play out across the state. while waterways like this are typically dry this time of year, some are filling up fast. while the rain is expected to end later on tonight, those hillside communities could remain vulnerable for a few more days. lester? >> all right, miguel, thank you. >>> we are getting a chilling new window this evening into the final days of the las vegas shooter from newly released surveillance footage showing him methodically amassing the arsenal of weapons inside the hotel where he would go on to kill 58 people at a concert outside in the worst mass shooting in modern american history. nbc's joe fryer has more. >> reporter: surveillance images show stephen paddock calmly checking in at the mandalay bay's vip desk. it's monday, september 25th, nearly a week before the shooting. after eating alone at a sushi restaura

attorney joyce vance.ation is going to come out about this physical threat and there are going to be quite a few details about it, joyce. what are the implications? >> you know, this is something of a bombshell, joe, this idea that someone physically threatened her could possibly be a crime so it may be she now feels like she can discuss details if perhaps she's reported a crime to police and there's going top some sort of ongoing criminal investigation into whoever threatened her. but this will also in many ways influence the judge who ultimately hear this is case, of course, a judge in california will have to decide if the nda is valid. >> if she signed an nda and then the attorney comes forward with evidence that either the president of the united states or somebody closely associated with the president doing the president's bidding, somebody that worked for the president several years went to her and physically threatened her and said physical harm would come of her if she did not remain silent -- >> o

had today other protests in dominican republic it was working very well we had very important that vance's and finally when the opposition and the government had to saying we traveled to santo domingo the president maybe now was there former presidents about there are from spain was there as well and when the opposition arrived they said they were not going to saying there was no agreement that the date was to close the twenty second of april so we kept on having conversations and finally it was the sated to move the date to the second part of may the last two weeks of may we don't have the precise they are ready but it has been announced we have been as a government and the electoral institutions as well they are independent but we are thinking about the country about democracy about the future and we want all the parties to take part in the election and that's the reason why we have president has agreed and presumably were ready the candidate of the revolutionary forces so our candidate will wait for the candidates of the opposition and we will have the elections in last may of course th

. >> reporter: pilot richard vance told investigators a tether from a harness worn by one of five passengers wrapped around the fuel shutoff lever accidentally cutting off the fuel supply, enusing the chopper's engine to fail sunday night. crews pulled the battered helicopter from the east river today. >> we will be working with the n.y.p.d. to recover any cameras or personal electronic devices from the aircraft. >> reporter: all five passengers on board died. divers had to cut them out of their safety harnesses. trevor kaddigan shot this video as the charter flight took off. did they walk you through how to get out of that harness in a hurry? >> not as well as they should have. >> reporter: eric adams was with the same group on another helicopter sunday. he took these pictures of the doomed chopper. here you can see the harness passengers wore. the metal ring on the back tethered them to the helicopter during the open-door flight. do you think you could have found your way out? >> it's very unlikely. i like to think i could have, but accidents happen fast. >> reporter: we went through a sim

. >> pilot richard vance told investigators a tether from a harness worn by one of the five passengerspped around the fuel shutoff lever accidentally, cutting off the fuel supply. causing the choppers engine off to fail sunday night. crews pulled the battered helicopter from the east river today. >> we will be working with the nypd to recover any cameras or personal electronic devices, from the air craft. >> all five passengers on board died. divers had to cut them out of their safety harnesses. trevor cadican shot this as charter flight took off. >> did they walk you through how to get out of the harness in a hurry. >> eric adams with the same group on another helicopter sunday night. he took these pictures of the doomed chopper. here you can see the harness passengers wore. the metal ring, tethered them to the helicopter during the open door flight. >> do you think you could have found your way out. >> unlikely. like to think i could have. accidents happen fast. >> we went for a similar open door helicopter ride over manhattan today. >> i'm wearing a harness in addition to the seatbe

. >> the trio of women who said bill clinton made unwanted sexual vances in the '80s and 90s. he denies it. >> when it was bill clinton's problem republicans tried to make it an issue. it doesn't work. why work 20 years later with his wife? >> i apologize to those tramps that have slept with my husband. >> the accusation is discredited. >> hillary clinton is the candidate. he was not implicated in any misconduct. she was not accused of doing anything untoward with regard to these women. >> it's about groping and touching against a woman's will. >> and rape? >> and rape. >> donald trump using that word unprompted during an interview last night with fox news sean hannity bringing up a long denied accusation against former president bill clinton death back to 1978. >> sean: that's pathetic. and nbc edited the on line version to remove mitchell. what we shao showed you is appalling. paula jones will react. the mainstream media shrouds itself in moral superiority against donald trump but defend all things clinton. take accusation about an alleged consensual encounter between trump

attorney joyce vance and john heilemann, our msnbc analyst. what can you report about what may or may not happen on friday? >> you had sam giving interview after interview after interview where he was really just charging, threatening not to participate in any of the mueller subpoena requests, saying he wasn't going to show up on friday, threatening to arrest him if they wanted to. but in my conversation with him after he finished all his cable news shows, he was in a much more somber mood. he said i'm really frustrated, they asked me for all of these e-mails, i e-mailed steve bannon and roger stone every day, it's so many hours of work they put me through, i don't understand i have to do, i didn't do anything wrong but i guess in the end i'll end up cooperating with them anyway. he said ideally he'd like muler to come back with a revised subpoena. he actually singled out carter page to me saying if he only got a new subpoena that didn't have page's name on it, he'd be happy to comply with it. he also said he'd never spoken to carter page. i'm

mark vance who lives on one of the hardest hit streets remembers the early morning hours of january 9 very well. >> the came to the door to try to get us out. we told them we were fine we had a lot of food and water. we had candles, fortunately. >> reporter: he rode out the mudslides with his family. even though his home is an island in the sea of destruction around him with personal belongings strewn along the roadside, he plans to stay. even though, there was a bright orange notice taped to the front of his home. >> we will stay. >> reporter: the forecast calls for significant amounts of rain, but the real question is how quickly will it come down? it's clear that mandatory evacuations will continue at least, for the next few days. >>> a dreary day in the south bay with heavy rain at times. downtown streets left a whole lot emptier than usual. >> we got more on the way. the heaviest rain for us will be from 9:00 tomorrow night until 9:00 in the morning on thursday. there is the atmospheric river. the area mainly dry -- the bay area mainly dry. a half inch to rain for now. a big prob

committee had one main goal to forestall any attempt to legislate against pollution its president vance jenkins made this unmistakably clear in one thousand nine hundred fifty four. the worst thing that can happen in many instances is that he's to passage of a law or laws for the control of a given air pollution situation. big oil began assembling a network companies supported colleges and think tanks like the stanford research institute was donations they returned the favor with a specific study studies like the robinson report which returned unsavory results were revised. forty years later exxon mobil executives were still pretending that these studies were never conducted. warning. that hundreds of people. are closing in the world temperatures in the room. earlier. trying to get evidence. as to whether human activities are. big oil used it's advance knowledge. to sow doubt and stymie legislation that might humble it but was this the only reason to secretly investigate global warming we drive two hundred kilometers to pennsylvania to visit a former exxon mobil employee. vs two area of

. >> reporter: the pilot, 33-year-old rick vance managed to escape. he said a harness got caught around a fuel supply. causing a catastrophic failure. there are questions about how the tourists were strapped in. all four were harnessed so they could take pictures with the door open. but they were so tight rescues struggled to rescue them from the helicopter. >> they don't know how to get out of it. >> reporter: the helicopter was operated by liberty helicopters. its website says it's been flying safely for over 30 years, but faa records show at least two other incidents including one in 2009 that killed nine people. now lawmakers are calling for answer. >> i am calling on the faa to issue an emergency order and suspend liberty helicopters 135 operating certificate. >> reporter: these types of tours are popular in new york city and helicopters are constantly buzzing up and down the city. >>> police have broken up a homeless camp built by a transient on top of the amtrak station roof. there were reports of someone lowering a bake frike from the station'

the pilot whose sources identify as richard vance made a may day call.ble to free himself, however, his five passengers who were harnessed in were trapped in sub 40-degree east river waters that were churning and as i mentioned frigid, unfortunately those five all passed away. witness recounted for us what it was like watching the pilot get out. >> one person sort of climbed out of the helicopter, climbed on to the raft and was calling, screaming for help. >> and we were told that the pilot was treated and released. he is at home this morning so far police have not yet identified the five who died. rob, jillian, back to you. rob: that is cold water, awful story. robert, thank you. jillian: 14 minutes until the top of the hour, did o.j. do it, that's the question everyone wants an answer to it this morning. >> i remember i grabbed the knife, do i remember that portion, taking the knife from charlie and to be honest after that i don't remember. rob: all right. jillian: last-filled hypothetical murder confession sparking a huge reaction online. carley shimk

policy is. >> joyce vance, i want to end the block by going back to a poll we showed last hour.e asked if they trusted robert mueller and wanted him to finish the investigation. 72% of americans want him to finish the investigation. only 11% think he should be fired. only one in ten think he should be fired and you start breaking this down party by party, joyce, the most telling part of this even among remembers, almost six in 10 republicans say let robert mueller finish the investigation. only 25% say he should be fired, only 8% of independents who will make a huge difference in the swing districts on whether snoeps is speaker of the house or paul ryan and 4% of democrats think he should be fired. john heilemann was talking about this that robert mueller has somehow become one of the most trusted men in america. there are few people in have this much kvs in the american people. so many institutions see their numbers collapsing, rural just seems to become more and more trusted with the american people everyday. how does that impact where we are in this investigation and where we

so that's why a lot of people are staying out. >> joyce vance, thank you for being on this morning. >ll ahead on "morning joe" -- >> hold it. joyce. would you like to weigh in -- apparently some kids out of brooklyn are tweeting that brooklyn barbecue is the best in the world and i know the good people of texas -- as ted cruz said and i actual actually agree with him wholeheartedly for once "bless your hearts, brooklyn." memphis, obviously offended. but would you like to speak for the alabama contingent on whether brooklyn barbecue is the best barbecue in the world. >> i saw those reports about brooklyn with great horror. that is not barbecue. y'all come back on down to birmingham and we'll eat some of the finest barbecue in the world here. >> joyce vance, thank you very much. >> i had a cot in the back of dreamland barbecue in tuscaloosa, alabama. >> that i believe. >> my friends said they were afraid i was going to get the gout. >> it's not a pretty sight. >>> jim himes is a leading voice on two of the day's most pressing issues, he is knee deep in the russia probe from his seat on