the fact is both sides support a variance. the da supports a variance. i'm not sure i support a variance. >> it wasn't brought up. >> i'm not sure what's before us any more. . >> i feel the deck has been vetted. >> may i say one last thing? part of the issue is the notice that -- using dimensions. five feet is the dimension with the deck at the top floor, third floor. that's measured from a bay that sticks out. >> a foot and a half, yeah. >> and the floor below that second floor is going to be wider, it's closer to 7 feet. just to make sure everybody understood that. >> so although the appellant has pointed out that there was a flaw in the 311 notification, i think he has had adequate contact, more than adequate contact with the project sponsor and the fact that i almost feel this has been over vetted. i am in the opinion of denying the appeal and upholding the permit. >> no comment. >> commissioners, just as a reminder, as commissioner fung stated, this is a variance and your task is to decide whether or not the 5 findings under planning code 305c have

the fact is both sides support a variance. the da supports a variance. i'm not sure i support a variance. >> it wasn't brought up. >> i'm not sure what's before us any more. . >> i feel the deck has been vetted. >> may i say one last thing? part of the issue is the notice that -- using dimensions. five feet is the dimension with the deck at the top floor, third floor. that's measured from a bay that sticks out. >> a foot and a half, yeah. >> and the floor below that second floor is going to be wider, it's closer to 7 feet. just to make sure everybody understood that. >> so although the appellant has pointed out that there was a flaw in the 311 notification, i think he has had adequate contact, more than adequate contact with the project sponsor and the fact that i almost feel this has been over vetted. i am in the opinion of denying the appeal and upholding the permit. >> no comment. >> commissioners, just as a reminder, as commissioner fung stated, this is a variance and your task is to decide whether or not the 5 findings under planning code 305c have

i intended an intent to grant the variance. subsequent to that the section 311 notification was performed in may, beginning on may 6. about 20 days into that mr. zaretsky made known that he did not receive notice or proper notice of the 311 or of the variance hearing notice. we asked him to hear what his concerns would be in response to our initial request about what concerns he had, we did not receive any concerns, it was more concern about the process, about the neat -- notice, about the hearing. we did extend the time by 30 days which is from the when the notice went out to when he contacted us saying he did not know about the project. also at that time when he stated he wasn't aware of the project, we contacted the project sponsor. he provided a signed letter from mr. zaretsky saying he had no issues with the project. there were no attached plans, there were concerns in our mind and we felt justified in extending the notification period. we asked for comments with regard to the project, i generally understood the impact on

sanchez. >> with regard to the variance for the protrusion the staff write up a report?> talking about and analyzing the effects of the veterinarians in terms of creating a superior design. >> not separate write-ups for it was something that there maybe memos from staff to the sponsor to giving guidance and direction but our final hearing at the planning commission did have a staff report and include a recommendations to approve and i know was supportive of design but the. >> the different like a dr request analysis you have actually other instances where the staff will write up a formal analysis there is if you go that relates to the surveillance or variance the variance document didn't say much about it. >> how they justify it is a superior design. >> i hear what you're saying it is something that decision the departments support for a project is something that is done by the counter planning division and through the design professionals one of the things that comes before me i'll route ask staff you know is that to be clear a design that the department supports and re

sanchez. >> with regard to the variance for the protrusion the staff write up a report?> talking about and analyzing the effects of the veterinarians in terms of creating a superior design. >> not separate write-ups for it was something that there maybe memos from staff to the sponsor to giving guidance and direction but our final hearing at the planning commission did have a staff report and include a recommendations to approve and i know was supportive of design but the. >> the different like a dr request analysis you have actually other instances where the staff will write up a formal analysis there is if you go that relates to the surveillance or variance the variance document didn't say much about it. >> how they justify it is a superior design. >> i hear what you're saying it is something that decision the departments support for a project is something that is done by the counter planning division and through the design professionals one of the things that comes before me i'll route ask staff you know is that to be clear a design that the department supports and re

what say you. >> close the public hearing on the variance on the third floor variance granted at the fourth story. >> i want to open this discussion. it's been a very long day. i think this item will take more than an hour. we have a half hour before the garage closes. >> we have two more items. i believe the 16th street would like to continue until at october 1st. >> the first on the agenda. >> you want to hear this next one? >> i don't think we are going to make it. we have to get to the garage. >> i don't think we'll make it. it takes about 10 minutes running over and bringing it back. >> i think there is consensus to adjourn the meeting. >> it's a continuance. >> we have to continue to pick a date for both. october 1st for the 16th street. >> again, october 1st or the 8 are probably the soonest hearing dates that are available. i suppose, well, the mission controls are next week. i would recommend the 1st on the 8th. that's entirely up to you, commissioners. you have the housing balance report and the facilities planning code amendment. i don't see why not. >> let's go for the fi

on the variance, close the public hearing and inclined that granted the variance for the 24 court andeny. >> dwu. >> sorry 22. >> 22. >> approving the conditional review. >> can i go first on the variances (laughter) we're taking ultimatum of them up in ordering arrest on the variance, close the public hearing and and grant the request. >> a motion that is second with an intent to disapprove the conditional use authorization. 22 and continue the matter to november 19th commissioner johns no commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore marry no commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes 6 to one is with commissioner antonini voting against >> zoning administrator, what say you? >> on the variance, close the public hearing and to decline the rear yard and take the matter in add investment. >> thank you commissioners that places you under our discretionary review calendar item number 202014 at golf street a discretionary review. >> thank you. good evening commissioner president fong and members of the commi

sanchez. >> with regard to the variance for the protrusion the staff write up a report?> talking about and analyzing the effects of the veterinarians in terms of creating a superior design. >> not separate write-ups for it was something that there maybe memos from staff to the sponsor to giving guidance and direction but our final hearing at the planning commission did have a staff report and include a recommendations to approve and i know was supportive of design but the. >> the different like a dr request analysis you have actually other instances where the staff will write up a formal analysis there is if you go that relates to the surveillance or variance the variance document didn't say much about it. >> how they justify it is a superior design. >> i hear what you're saying it is something that decision the departments support for a project is something that is done by the counter planning division and through the design professionals one of the things that comes before me i'll route ask staff you know is that to be clear a design that the department supports and re

sanchez. >> with regard to the variance for the protrusion the staff write up a report?> talking about and analyzing the effects of the veterinarians in terms of creating a superior design. >> not separate write-ups for it was something that there maybe memos from staff to the sponsor to giving guidance and direction but our final hearing at the planning commission did have a staff report and include a recommendations to approve and i know was supportive of design but the. >> the different like a dr request analysis you have actually other instances where the staff will write up a formal analysis there is if you go that relates to the surveillance or variance the variance document didn't say much about it. >> how they justify it is a superior design. >> i hear what you're saying it is something that decision the departments support for a project is something that is done by the counter planning division and through the design professionals one of the things that comes before me i'll route ask staff you know is that to be clear a design that the department supports and re

the fact is both sides support a variance. the da supports a variance. i'm not sure i support a variance. >> it wasn't brought up. >> i'm not sure what's before us any more. . >> i feel the deck has been vetted. >> may i say one last thing? part of the issue is the notice that -- using dimensions. five feet is the dimension with the deck at the top floor, third floor. that's measured from a bay that sticks out. >> a foot and a half, yeah. >> and the floor below that second floor is going to be wider, it's closer to 7 feet. just to make sure everybody understood that. >> so although the appellant has pointed out that there was a flaw in the 311 notification, i think he has had adequate contact, more than adequate contact with the project sponsor and the fact that i almost feel this has been over vetted. i am in the opinion of denying the appeal and upholding the permit. >> no comment. >> commissioners, just as a reminder, as commissioner fung stated, this is a variance and your task is to decide whether or not the 5 findings under planning code 305c have

i intended an intent to grant the variance. subsequent to that the section 311 notification was performed in may, beginning on may 6. about 20 days into that mr. zaretsky made known that he did not receive notice or proper notice of the 311 or of the variance hearing notice. we asked him to hear what his concerns would be in response to our initial request about what concerns he had, we did not receive any concerns, it was more concern about the process, about the neat -- notice, about the hearing. we did extend the time by 30 days which is from the when the notice went out to when he contacted us saying he did not know about the project. also at that time when he stated he wasn't aware of the project, we contacted the project sponsor. he provided a signed letter from mr. zaretsky saying he had no issues with the project. there were no attached plans, there were concerns in our mind and we felt justified in extending the notification period. we asked for comments with regard to the project, i generally understood the impact on

. >> that's correct i believe the variance were filed at a point in time but not sure that is pursued. >> commissioner. >> why not hear the rest. >> thank you. >> thank you anything inspector duf duffy. >> commissioners joe duffy guy i didn't hear any building code issues brought up i think the permit was reviewed properly by dbi through the proper channels where the building engineers planned checked i'm sure reviewed it thoroughly i don't have any questions. >> any public comment on this item? >> please step forward. >> good evening president and board members i'm shawn i live across the street from the the proposed project and i'm also an architect i've practiced in san francisco for roughly 27 years and when i first started practice a couple of notification process started with the interim controls in 1988 it was codified with the 311 process and the 36 process has a simple basis when the project is essentially presented to the public through the notification process that it has been reviewed by staff and that it meets the design planning code this is the public trust that this pr

the project proposes to add this and a rear yard variance is being requested to reduce the yard variance requirement and this fails to meet the planning commission's idea and it's not meeting this because the proposed project oefrdz the rooftop. no. 2, the extensive shadow of the additional two floors will have an impact on the surrounding neighborhoods and does not comply with the general plan because of the additional two floors do not protect, preserve or enhance the desirable quality of the unique character of the city. this fails to meet planning code section which are required for the zoning administrator to grant variance. when there are no exceptional or circumstances applied to those involve apply to the properties in the neighborhood and the provisions of this code would not result for the hardship of the applicant. this variance is not necessary for the substantial prooits of subject property: the granting of the variance would be detriment to the public welfare and adversely affect the san francisco's general plan because of the reduction in the rear yard requirement does not

on the variance, close the public hearing and inclined that granted the variance for the 24 court andy. >> dwu. >> sorry 22. >> 22. >> approving the conditional review. >> can i go first on the variances (laughter) we're taking ultimatum of them up in ordering arrest on the variance, close the public hearing and and grant the request. >> a motion that is second with an intent to disapprove the conditional use authorization. 22 and continue the matter to november 19th commissioner johns no commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore marry no commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes 6 to one is with commissioner antonini voting against >> zoning administrator, what say you? >> on the variance, close the public hearing and to decline the rear yard and take the matter in add investment. >> thank you commissioners that places you under our discretionary review calendar item number 202014 at golf street a discretionary review. >> thank you. good evening commissioner president fong and members of the commiss

a parking variance, this variance, this conditional use. most of all, 20 more feet and exception to your bulk limits. 2 more floors of condoes add that level sell for 4 thousand dollars a square foot and that is about 30 thousand feet at least. 120 million dollars goody from you a 20 feet you don't have to give them. what are we getting back? the profit from that after development cost, 30 million? pick a number. 25 million? what do you get back? what is the sit a getting back for giving 20 more feet, nothing. you are not getting anything back. why don't you tell them double the inclusionary which means double the fee in this case from 9 million to 18 million and we'll giver you that 20 feet and 120 millions. that is what you need to do and whailt the department has to use the leverage it has and ever exception and variance that you grant is worth money, big money and get us more affordable housing or at least more money for it. otherwise [inaudible] it down. >> good evening i'm [inaudible] from south of market action committee. i haven't a

and so that's a substantial reduction if the 25 percent based on the variance. >> so it is a modification under the thirty 9 and - >> understood. >> a couple of competing issues this is a corner property for corner properties we seek to have the building wall along the street frontage so in this case they're doing that along golden gate with the rear yard with the 34 feet depth their maintaining that street wall there and one of the problems with not having a greater courtyard and the fact the depth of the lot going on along hyde street is 767 feet if deeper than providing a larger courtyard but finding a greater courtyard reduces the number of units and reduces the bmr. >> i'm raising that point of where different - the police and building code requirements for time and days of construction are extremely liberal i think 7 to 7. >> 7 days a week. >> 7:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m., 7 days a week. >> that's no constraints. >> it's a condition that politics to all conditions in the city. >> i've seen the conditions the planning conditions that are set days and times. >> where the environmental revie

now we know it was one or two and the variance can be explained by barometric pressure.er goodell overshot on this thinking bob kraft and tom brady would go along for the ride and play ball because brady is the face of the league and the rest of it and seemed to have a lot to lose by fighting back. i will say this for tom brady and i know it from talking to the players association. he at any time want to go down as the person who made it labor press tent in the nfl to hand over your personal cell phone. he didn't want to be that guy. that's something to say. >> he fought the law and the law didn't win. >> that's true. >> the law did win in his favor. dave, thanks. >> final thoughts. remember this when you hear about how the evil teachers' unions won't let us fire the bad teachers i.'s the same process that ensures people get a fair hearing that keeps tom brady and keeps those teachers. tomorrow i will be joined by donald trump's former top adviser roger stone and the protester who was knocked in the head outside trump's press conference today. that's tomorrow night. righ

there is also a fair amount of variance in how the ncaa testing program goes, and i just think it's ana that we probably need to spend some more time on. i don't think we do as much as the national governing bodies in our olympic programs, and we, i think we can probably do better. i don't know if it's a conference initiated program. we have a random drug testing program in the big 1 and i think most conferences do, but we're really testing a very, very small number of the total athletes on each campus. i think we end up testing between 40 and 60 on each campus. so it really is not all that impactful. and i think we probably have more that we can do. in the case of the concussions, we have really tried to lead on that. we, the big 12, has just put in place a rule that cut our full contact practices by 50% going into this year. we went from three days a week to two days a week. we are still higher than what the nfl allows. the nfl only allows 11 days of full contact after the first game. and so we're in -- in my estimation, a bit of a compromising position. but the issue of concussions

the song sounded basically the same, but you hear these tiny differences, tiny bits of the variance.rump could had more in that direction, where the greatest someare still there, but things are a little bit new and more conventional at the same time. super john ellis, bush's pac, is out with a new tv ad in iowa, new hampshire, and as soon south carolina that promotes his record as governor of florida. >> the state was florida, the governor was jeb bush. proven conservative, real results. jeb. at the same time, jeb's official campaign shows a video of him speaking spanish and his wife speaking english. spanish] >> we have celebrations with the family. we keep our traditions. our faith, friends and family. john: mark, in the past couple months, jeb bush has been beaten bloody by this campaign. to the messages in these ad/videos constitute the road to recovery for this man? mark: this is not an audible reaction to jump. -- two trump. this is what they have been planning in his campaign all along. they coordinated before the separation of the two entities. the super pac would tell people

they should be aware of his views on issues like this, and the fact that they are at variance with the constitution of the united states. >> bill schneider. thank you very much. >> the texas teen that got in trouble over a home made clock has withdrawn from the texas school that suspended him. today his family took him out of mcarthur high school. he was arrested after bringing the clock to school. he wanted to show it off to a teacher. he wasn't charged he was suspended from school. we taking hundreds of feet above the ground to see how california's drought threatens trees thousands of years home. a former c.e.o. facing decades in prison for his failed decision of pursuit in >>> a former peanut company exec has been sentenced to 28 years in prison for his role in a salmonella outbreak. he owned the company, after an outbreak killed nine, sickened hundreds more, triggering a large recall. he knew and shipped tainted peanut butter, faking the results of lab tests >>> a group of u.s. doctors say e-cigarettes cigarettes have too men unknowns to recommend them to smokers that want to quit.

there is quite a variance here. 72 in san ramon and 50 in half moon bay.g down. 56 in napa. you can see it is absolutely fog free. warm to hot. records are possible on sunday and it is going to get cooler as fall starts on wednesday. look at the satellite and the radar. the high pressure is building in and as the high pressure comes in we are looking at hot days. i noy a lot of people are not enjoying the heat. it will not last long so that's the bright side. upper 90s on saturday. as we head toward sunday we will see the triple digits inland. not as hot over the weekend. the heat eases as we head into the workweek. back to school for those kids 90s and 100's in the valley. upper 40s around half moon bay and napa. when you get going tomorrow morning you just might need that extra thin layer. later in the day you will need to lose the lay injure. when you look at the temperatures you will see exactly how hot it is going to get. 97 in gilroy and 94 in morgan hill. low thients san jose -- low 90s in san jose. on the peninsula you will need the sunscreen. palo

there is also a fair amount of variance in how the ncaa testing program goes, and i just think it's an area that we probably need to spend some more time on. i don't think we do as much as the national governing bodies in our olympic programs, and we, i think we examican probably do b. i don't know if it's a conference niche eiginitiated p. we are testing a very, very small number of the total athletes on each campus. i think we end up testing between 40 and 60 on each campus. so it really is not all that impactful. and i, i think we probably have more that we can do. the, in the case of the concussions, we have really tried to lead on that. we, the big 12 has just put in place a rule that cut our full contact practices by 50%, going into this year. we went from three days a week to two days a week. we are still higher than what the nfl allows. the nfl only allows 11 days of full contact after the first game. and so we're, in my estimate age ation in a little bit of a compromising position. but the issue of concussions is obviously acute in college football, and we've changed the rules

there is quite a variance here. 72 in san ramon and 50 in half moon bay. you know where it is cooling down. napa. you can see it is absolutely fog free. warm to hot. records are possible on sunday and it is going to get cooler as fall starts on wednesday. look at the satellite and the radar. the high pressure is building in and as the high pressure comes in we are looking at hot days. i noy a lot of people are not enjoying the heat. it will not last long so that's the bright side. upper 90s on saturday. as we head toward sunday we will see the triple digits inland. not as hot over the weekend. the heat eases as we head into the workweek. back to school for those kids 90s and 100's in the valley. upper 40s around half moon bay and napa. when you get going tomorrow morning you just might need that extra thin layer. later in the day you will need to lose the lay injure. when you look at the temperatures you will see exactly how hot it is going to get. 97 in gilroy and 94 in morgan hill. low thients san jose -- low 90s in san jose. on the peninsula you will ne

alternatives including thee or her or the variance of they. >>> in tonight's health alert, could a drug as simple and cheap as aspirin be the wonder drug? combining therapy with aspirin substantially slows the growth of bowel and skin cancer. aspirin blocks production of a molecule that lets tumors evade defenses. so, now scientists will confirm findings in humans. happens in us. sports. field. we know who was not on the field tonight. now we take a look at who was. straight ahead, the final games for the locals. the jets at home against the eagles. they are up for grabs. we will head to the meadow lands, plus the giants on the road against the patriots. brady might be the >>> are you surprised brady didn't play or show his face on the field? >> not surprised he didn't play. surprised he wasn't around for a little longer. tom brady's suspension overturned pending appeal. and on anything but a routine day in the nfl, teams get back to their routines. the focus has been on the patriots. so doesn't it make perfect sense the giants wrap things up on the road in new england? the starters on

alternatives including thee or her or the variance of they. >>> in tonight's health alert, could a drug as simple and cheap as aspirin be the wonder drug? combining therapy with aspirin substantially slows the growth of bowel and skin cancer. aspirin blocks production of a molecule that lets tumors evade defenses. findings in humans. >> it doesn't count until that happens in us. rob powers is up next with sports. >> football on and off the field. we know who was not on the field tonight. now we take a look at who was. straight ahead, the final games for the locals. the jets at home against the eagles. they are up for grabs. we will head to the meadow lands, plus the giants on the road against the patriots. brady might be the big i'm giving you a gallon of bp gas. because you're my best friend. i'm giving you a gallon of bp gas. because you're my best friend. why are you giving me a gallon of... because you're my best friend. i'm giving you a gallon of bp gas. because you're my best... get gas rewards for three friends and even one for yourself. when you sign up for bp driver rewards. it

reflect the ethnic diversity of this city, and the theme of the mass, catholic masses have slight variances in them that they give them theme, the theme of this mass will be peace and justice, reflecting pope francis's emphasis on the dispossessed and marginalized of our society. and as we were mentioning, at the top there, he will also, when he gets to this place, step into a mini popemobile and make a circuit of the 20,000 member arena, all of those people there to mingle with them. that ask one more thing that is -- that is one more thing that is giving police a little bit of anxiety as they prepare to get security ready but again the secret service and swiss guard and police working hard to keep them safe. live at madison square garden, lou young, cbs 2 news. >> so many looking forward to having him. lou, thank you very much. cbs 2 is your source for the papal visit, he arrives september 24 and leaves the 26th. look for live coverage, right here on cbs 2 and streaming live on www.cbs-newyork.com. >>> and coming up, this noon, confusion as people find an alternative to walking. riding al

a parking variance, this variance, this conditional use.20 more feet and exception to your bulk limits. 2 more floors of condoes add that level sell for 4 thousand dollars a square foot and that is about 30 thousand feet at least. 120 million dollars goody from you a 20 feet you don't have to give them. what are we getting back? the profit from that after development cost, 30 million? pick a number. 25 million? what do you get back? what is the sit a getting back for giving 20 more feet, nothing. you are not getting anything back. why don't you tell them double the inclusionary which means double the fee in this case from 9 million to 18 million and we'll giver you that 20 feet and 120 millions. that is what you need to do and whailt the department has to use the leverage it has and ever exception and variance that you grant is worth money, big money and get us more affordable housing or at least more money for it. otherwise [inaudible] it down. >> good evening i'm [inaudible] from south of market action committee. i haven't agreed with joh

no variance on how people felt about this mass. josh einiger near the stage where they are now cleaning up. >> reporter: you know, bill, they've been planning this event for years. they knew the pope was going to be here one year ago. all of this will be gone in a matter of days. the pope was just minutes after the end of this event. the pope, in fact, barely wheels up before the set start today come down on the ben franklin parkway. the sight of the world meeting of families, which was the grand finale. in fact the whole reason for the pope's historic visit to the place. officials say early estimates approach nearly a million visitors from around the world who came to see pope francis celebrate his open air mass in a town that hasn't seen a papal visit in four decades. people of different backgrounds and countries and religions. they stood shoulder to shoulder united as one. >> it's a humbling experience. knowing that my inperfections make us a perfect, perfect world. it's just beautiful. >> reporter: you thought we had bad street

>> we think so, but that's with a wide degree of variance.e think the chinese currency will appreciate. it will depreciate more slowly. interesting at the g-20, the chinese officials said they thought they were almost at the bottom but they didn't say they were at the bottom. so maybe they're expecting nor go. i think we have to wait until we actually see those conditions have stabilized before there's any hope for that. >> when we consider the recent volt till over the whole over the summer, has china caused that or is that a justifiable cause? or is china concerned with itself at the moment for a bit of a bounce? >> well, look, i think the china slowdown is real. and the market seeing the depreciation in the yuan is an indication that the chinese officials have backed away that everything is fine. the yen continues to strengthen, many of the major yen countries have that. it's a very difficult situation. very few investors want to catch that. >> steven, when do you think the fed will hike rates? and what's your call for the u.s. dollar agai

there is also a fair amount of variance and the ncaa testing program goes. i just think it's an area that we probably need to spend some more time on. i don't think we do as much as the national governing bodies in our olympic programs, and we, i think we can probably do better. i don't know if it's a conference initiated program. we have a random drug testing program in the big 12, and i think most conferences do. but we are really testing a very, very small number of the total athletes on each campus. i think we conduct testing between 40 and 60 on each campus. so it really does not all that impactful. i think we probably have more that we can do. indicates that the concussions, we have really tried to lead him that. the big 12 has just put in place a rule that cut our full contact practices by 50%, going into this year. we went from three days a week to two days a week. we are still higher than what the nfl allows. the nfl only allows 11 days of full contact after the first game. and so we are come in my estimation, a little bit of a compromising position

republican controlled legislature gives abortion clinics 60 days to obtain an exception known as a varianceent transfer agreement with a private hospital. the requirement, another of the legislators restrictions because of private hospitals makes them unwilling to enter into agreements with abortion clinics. the ohio department of public health allows clinics to remain open without an agreement in place and must be renewed every year. the planned parenthood clinic is awaiting renewal as is women's med, another in dayton. the clock on both clinics starts ticking down on september 29th, the day the law goes into effect. the planned parenthood facility in cincinnati waited more than a year to receive its latest exception and waited for two years for its variance. if the ohio health department doesn't move much faster than it has in the past and approve the exemption within 60 days of the 29th, both clinics will lose their licenses effectively wiping out abortion access in southwestern ohio. the loss would mean women in the region who are seeking an abortion will have to travel 220 miles roundt

you know this tracks from fiscal year 2010 to 2014 as you can see before the arching a a slight variance for hospitals in terms of their actual expenditures from 2013 to 20145 hospitals got a st. luke's oar st. francis and as far as i am concerned and sf g h kaiser and chinese and ucsf actually experienced increases in charity care expenditures that is the kind of various in the data and one thing to note we've decided in the community meeting worth noting the hospital reporting periods are not uniform some hospitals report to us on a fiscal year from july to june and some hospitals report on a calendar year into january to december as you can see in the slide the hospitals with the asterisk they denote the actual hospitals that are reporting on a fiscal year so the hospital timelines in terms of the fiscal year years don't exactly match up as you can see within that group the calendar hospitals at the top and the fiscal year hospitals at the bottom there is variance variation as well could lead to that is not necessarily the reporting period but the specific hospital characters that wil

the question from the audience is a variance on that. how do you see resilient infrastructure being adapted in the nation, particularly in cities that will be affected by climate change? ben: i will take a bite of a small piece of that. have had a fair amount of interaction with the dutch in thinking about coastal management at ocean beach, certainly in the northeast as well, and because of the dutch, of course, they have an 800 years history of managing their coasts. from a certain lens, a certain traditional environmental lens, there is something very troubling about that sort of high intervention, inventive landscape that is the dutch coast. on the other hand, increasingly, we can no longer pretend that nature is out there as this kind of pristine wilderness for us, and our job is to be just a small as we can be. our virtue lies in being a small entity and in letting the wilderness happened. increasing the, we are in a situation where our footprints are on a global scale, hence our necessity for managing processes and we have to meet