communications diplomat foreign policy expert of the security policy center of defense strategies oleksandr kharar. oleksandr i congratulate you and i am glad to see you on our air yes, good evening mr. sergey , thank you for the invitation, you see too let's start with the results because well, e- this is what i have been watching and reading. over the past two days , someone is saying that this one is successful for ukraine. annual plan or annual plans and yet we remain at that point with the exception of the adoption of the decision on the creation of the ukraine nato council and the guarantees from the big seven that were signed today in vilnius . what do you say? how do you evaluate the results of this summit , what did it give what did he not add to ukraine? well, you know, he did not become historic because , of course, if ukraine received a clear signal and the start of the political process of ukraine's accession to nato, it is clear that nato's accession took place or later after the end of this war, and this formula of absolutely all of us i mean the ukrainian authorities and the ukrai

next hour with our guests from veterans of the russian-ukrainian war oleksiy hetman diplomat oleksandr khara and people's deputy of ukraine mykola knyazhytskyi let's start with information about the losses of the occupiers in ukraine in ukraine 231,000 30 russians have already died in the last day alone the armed forces of ukraine have destroyed 770 people at the beginning of the great war russians have already lost in ukraine 4:059 tanks 7908 armored fighting vehicles 4252 artillery systems 647 rocket launchers 394 air defense equipment 315 aircraft 309 helicopters 6,843 units of automobile equipment 18 ships boats 1264 cruise missiles 3602 drones 590 units of special equipment for those who are currently watching us on youtube i want to invite you friends to take part in our survey today we ask you about whether the branch of the orthodox church in ukraine should be banned yes no please vote in to our survey or write your version in the comments, i want to introduce our guest today, this is oleksiy hetman, a veteran of the russian-ukrainian war, a major of the national guard in the reserve

we can read it well, i introduce my next guest with whom i continued today’s program, this is oleksandr kharaon foreign affairs and security who politicians of the center for defense strategies mr. oleksandr vitayu glory to ukraine to the heroes thank you for joining well, let's talk with mr. volodymyr tsibulko, uh, a lot about putin lukashenka, about their a-ah, now they are meeting. and a bromance, i don't know what to call it. a romance from a romance, but i didn't talk to him. what i want to talk about with you right now is the shelling not just of the center of uh, odessa, but the shelling as a result of which one of the rockets hit the holy transfiguration cathedral of odessa is this done on purpose or is it a malfunction of high-precision weapons? well, i think so they went to a church that legally belongs to a branch in ukraine under the control of the russian orthodox church. it was intentional, but knowing the accuracy of their own rockets of analogavnetov e-e weapons, of course that e-e when they aimed at the center. well, i understand that e-e it is possible to invent some e-e rel

this is oleksandr khara, an expert on foreign and security policy at the center for defense strategiesdr vitayu. glory to the heroes of ukraine. thank you for joining. well, let's go, mr. volodymyr tzibulko and i talked a lot about putin. lukashenka about their meeting now. i don't know what to call it. a romance with a romance, but i didn't talk to him. what i want to talk to you about right now is the shelling not just of the center of odesa, but the shelling as a result of which one of the rockets hit the transfiguration cathedral in odesa. is this done on purpose or is it a malfunction of high-precision weapons? well, i think that they went to a church that legally belongs to the controlled russian orthodox church branch in ukraine. sleepy, but knowing the accuracy of its own missiles of analognyatov e-e weapons of course, what if they aimed at the center? well, i understand that it is possible to invent some kind of objects related to the ukrainian government or military objects, but understanding such accuracy. of course, a normal bull of the country, a normal military one, would

this is oleksandr khara, an expert on foreign and security policy of the center for defense strategiesthank you to ukraine for joining. well, come on, i and mr. volodymyr tsibulko, uh, talked a lot about putin, lukashenka, about their a-ah, now they're meeting. and bromance , i don't know what to call it. roman from romance, but i didn't talk to him. one thing that you are talking about now i want to talk about the shelling not just of the center of odesa, but the shelling as a result of which one of the rockets hit the holy transfiguration cathedral of odesa, is this done on purpose or is it a failure of high-precision weapons ? well, i think that they went to a church that legally belongs to a branch controlled by the russian orthodox church in ukraine. it was intentional, but knowing the accuracy of the own rockets of analogovnetov e-weapons, of course, when they aimed at the center, no, i understand that it is possible there to invent some e-e related to the ukrainian authorities or the military objects, but understanding such accuracy of course, a normal bull of the country would

we can read it well, i introduce my next guest with whom i continued today’s program, this is oleksandr kharaty policy of the center for defense strategies oleksandr vitayu kudos to ukraine for joining well, let's talk with mr. volodymyr tzibulko, uh, a lot about putin lukashenka, about their a-ah, now their meeting and romance, i don't know what to call it. a romance from a romance, but i didn't talk to him alone, what i want to talk about now is the shelling, not just the center, uh, of odesa, the shelling, as a result of which one of the rockets hit the holy transfiguration cathedral of odesa , is this being done on purpose, or is this a high failure - high-precision weapons well, i think that they are in a temple that legally belongs under russian control the branch of the orthodox church in ukraine was intentional, but knowing the accuracy of its own rockets of analogavnetov e-e weapons, of course what e-e when they aimed at the center well, i understand that e-e you can invent some e-e related to the ukrainian authorities or military objects, but understanding such accuracy of course, a

of the g7 about expectations and reality at the summit. of the center for defense strategies, oleksandr khara , we are currently in touch with serhii rakhmanin , people's deputy of ukraine and member of the verkhovna rada committee on national security of defense and intelligence, in my opinion, this is the correct name of this committee p. serhiy i congratulate you and i am glad to see you on our broadcast . congratulations, thank you. let's start with the results, because someone says that this is a victory. someone says that this is treason. in vilnyusk, we will receive an official invitation to nato, unfortunately, this did not happen, and zelensky said that no decisions can be made without the participation of ukraine regarding the future of ukraine in nato. do you consider this summit successful for ukraine, i would call the results of this exactly neither a defeat nor a victory. i expected something similar in principle. i would call it a fixation of the status quo. nato is not yet ready to see ukraine as a member of the alliance nato could not refuse ukraine in the current situation b

in the comments below, we can contact oleksandr khara, a diplomat and an expert on issues of foreign curity and politics of the center of defense strategies, oleksandr. i congratulate you. i am glad to see you on our broadcast. good evening, mr. serhii. the iliac bitterness of the former minister of the so-called minister the defense of the dpr, the first accused of extremism, was put in a prison until september 18th, and well, it looks like the terrorist putin arrested the terrorist . words addressed to putin and everyone said, well, behind him there is some kind of kremlin tower it stands and this tower actually covers strilkovo, well, you know, literally a couple of days ago, we had an expert conference on the crimean platform, and we discussed the possible future of the russian federation. there are different approaches to how we evaluate what this entity is. in my deep conviction, modern russia is an unsustainable state, an unsustainable society and an unsustainable leadership. in fact, putin is now trying to protect it. after he was there for three days, it is unknown where he w

dropped it, i mean the telethon, write your option in the comments below, we are in touch with oleksandr kharaan expert on foreign policy and security, and the policy of the center for defense strategies, oleksandr. i congratulate you. i am glad to see you on our broadcast. good evening , mr. serhii. our conversation with the situation around strilkov because today a whole epic drama was played out in moscow by the detention of igor strelkov gorkin, the former minister of the so-called minister of defense of the dpr, the first one to be accused of extremism, he was put in jail until september 18th and well, it looks like a terrorist putin has arrested a terrorist, the accuser accuses him of extremism through the terrorist court of moscow, and well, it all looks like a battle of spiders in a jar, how are you? tell me, what do you say about this, how do you perceive what is happening with the arrow because the arrow is one of those who very often said insulting words to putin, and everyone said, well, there is a kremlin tower behind him, and this tower actually covers strelkov. well, you know, j

it was oleksandr khara, a diplomat . we ask about this or are you satisfied with the only telethon?watch it, but i gave up your version for the moment. 69% of the viewers we surveyed on youtube said that they were dissatisfied with the only telethon. 15% were satisfied. 10 watched it, but i will quit. well, that is, 80% of our audience does not watch and is not satisfied with the only telethon. we continue the survey and at the end of the program, we will summarize the results of this vote . mykola knyazhytsky p mykola i congratulate you and i am glad to see you on the air, let's start with tkachenko's resignation, because tkachenko is resigning for the second time in three years, and twice the reason for this was cinema. once was a state cinema, and the other - this cinema, 400 million allocated for the production of series, received a lot of attention. there was also a lot of attention in social networks. they also wrote about what series the state is going to film with state funds for the state tv channel. yesterday, after the obvious reaction of your social networks , president

and at the end of the program we will sum up the results of this vote further on we will have oleksandr kharalomat expert on foreign and security policy of the center of defense strategies i congratulate you mr. oleksandr and i am glad that you joined our program, thank you for the invitation , let's start with the last message that was circulated with the armed forces of ukraine just a few minutes ago, they officially report the possible preparation of provocations on the territory in the near future of the zaporizhzhia npp on july 4, according to operational information, foreign objects similar to explosive devices were placed on the outer curve of the third and fourth power units of the station. nato is a dutch admiral. he says that if there is an explosion at a gas station there, it will affect not only ukraine and russia, but the whole planet in general, and europe, in particular, according to your opinion, if russia dares to any provocations at the zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant, perhaps at the kursk nuclear power plant or at some nuclear power plant located on the territory of the uk

basis of the same of the project and have a visual similarity, analysts write a defect express oleksandr kharaplomat, expert of the center for defense strategies is already with us on the air p oleksandriya greetings good morning how do you generally assess the guarantees of security and support that will be given to ukraine in the final documents of the summit that is ongoing in vilnius, in particular as for long-term support for many years, well, first of all , it should not be called security guarantees, since security guarantees can be either nuclear weapons , of course, not our option, or the fifth article of the washington treaty well, we can see that she left this policy of ambivalence too much, on the one hand, confirming that nato will be happy to see us but under certain conditions , and i absolutely agree with the minister . the wording is vague, it definitely does not encourage us and the third option - this is an agreement such as, for example, between the united states and japan, not israel , i will tell you why. that is, in fact, security guarantees - these are guarantees that i