roksila andriivna, what is your position?are already in a substantial discussion, we have not moved on to the amendments, but i will tell you why i asked my mother, because she has 32 years of teaching experience, not all teachers have that much experience, and if we are talking about a teacher who comes after university, then he has... a much lower salary, before taxation, it will be about uah 13,000, and this is really little, and after taxation it is even less, and by the way, i want to address the education committee, on behalf of all physics teachers, i know that you hear us, that physics teachers, on sorry they don't get paid extra for the notebooks and for checking the notebooks they check no less than teachers of the ukrainian language, for example, hon. colleagues, look, i have a big request, we are currently discussing substantive amendments , i want to remind you that we, who were in the amendments, to change the name of the program in such a wording, other incomes, please, let's still deal with these issues, we wi

please, ruslana andriivna.tro serhiyovych, the average monthly salary of the sap prosecutor is uah 14,500. do you really think that any of those ukrainians who are watching us today sympathize. to the special anti-corruption prosecutor's office, that we did not add money to them, dear colleagues, the 319th amendment, authored by mykysha, by the committee rejected, please vote. for 37, no decision was made. next amendment: 320th, 321st, 322nd, 323rd, 324th, amendment, razumkov, dmytro oleksandrovych , please. dear colleagues, you know, thank you, mykhailovych, roxan andriivna, but we figured out where 100 is, 51 + 51, and 200 is allocated, how many, correct, 272, where else did they divide, well, i understand that it is not divided yet, you will divide even after you vote for this law, but where, where are the others, where are the 100? 701 to 171 million, i think that we will reach the end of the meeting and a logical conclusion, let's understand where they went, maybe mykhailovych will be able to answer this q

andriivna, by the way, it will be interesting for oleksandr bakumov to hear the answer to this questionoutgoing letter number 675 dated august 21, 2023, signed by the president of the national academy of legal sciences volodymyr zhuraravel, in which it is said that the academy of legal sciences submits proposals for reducing budget allocations in 2023 according to the attached form. in this form of reduction in two programs: scientific and organizational activities of the presidium, the savings were made in connection with the death of active members, academicians and a corresponding member of the national academy of legal sciences. this saved 216,1000 hryvnias. another 5,000 hryvnias were saved due to the fact that the rent was not paid during the martial law period and savings were made due to vacancies. thank you, 927 smartly, please, thank you raksolana andriivna for a comprehensive answer to this question as well, really you, your work deserves in great respect. i would like to go back to one thing... on the funding of broadcasting, where they plan to go and how they correlate with

yes, thank you, rukslan andriivna, do you want to answer?ays have a desire to answer all questions, once again, this is not the ministry of agrarian policy, this is the state fisheries agency, which is not a part of the ministry of mines, which is a subordinate, what is actually in the ministry of agricultural policy, are we increasing this the budget for three months of the year, the remaining expenses for business support, definitely yes, for example, we are increasing expenses for the innovation development fund under the ministry of digital transformation, which will deal not only with agricultural business, but also with innovative business, that's in short, thank you, dear colleagues, next comes a whole block of amendments authored by the ironworker, the guy came up, said that instead of all the amendments, he is asking for 4 minutes, i understand correctly, volodymyrovych, you are there, there is no people's deputy sabol, other co-authors, amendment 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120 , 121, 122, 123, 124, 125, 126. 127, 128,

thank you, ruslan oleksiiovych, i think that ruslan andriivna will be able to answer, please andriivna, no, not quite so, because 272 million is for the ministry of finance, as the chief administrator, the state treasury service receives from an increase in expenditures by 51.6 million hryvnias, this is a salary with accruals and with deductions, i.e. accruals by the state does, the deduction is deducted from the employee's salary, so 45,000 will definitely not be there, i will tell you in my next answer what the approximate amounts are. thank you, please, let's move on, dear colleagues, 239, tymoshenko, yuliya volodymyrivna, please, mykhailo mykhailovych tsimbalyuk, 239, mykhailo tsimbalyuk, homeland, dear colleagues, well today , after listening to the presentation on these draft laws of the ministers, and you know, the position is surprising, rather, the communication style itself. minister of finance with people's deputies. such an instructive tone, one gets the impression that he is speaking not as the minister of finance of the government appointed by the parliament, but as a mat

thank you, roxelana andriivna, let's move on.ext, dmytro oleksandro 71sha, 72, 73, 74, 75, i'm right, voiced, please, dmytro oleksandrovich, and ruslan oleksiyovych, there are no important or unimportant amendments, if the deputy considers them important enough, he has the right to talk about them, this is the first, second. and we are not talking about approaches now, we are talking about the fact that if the chairman of the committee now agrees to increase what our team, the smart policy team, has proposed, take money from the above-mentioned government, the cabinet of ministers, the ministries, and increase spending on the armed forces and the ministry defenses on... which are proposed edits, now we will remove everything, let's move on, what questions, if such a position is agreed upon, we are ready to vote for it and not waste time, but i understand that for many colleagues you need to repeat it several times, that's why i am forced, and that's it not for you, not for rakselana andreevna, for many other colleagues, so that t

and colleagues, you, you are well done for bringing flowers to rexelana andriivna.is very good, but it would be better if you were sitting in the hall and working, and not running around somewhere, and rexelana andriivna should really be at the end the meeting to applaud, because she is a big well done, and held this meeting, it is true, it is true, but returning to the amendments, you are destroying ukrainian business, which, according to your own words, protects... the state on a par with the armed forces, because it is ukrainian business finances the taxes from which the ukrainian army is financed, it is the fops, it is medium and small businesses that do this, i would like everyone to remember this, but instead of allocating 300 million in aid for business, you allocate 225 million for providing bepu, and by the fact is that they receive about 700 million per year, and they returned it last year, they are 32, if i am not mistaken, explain to me this missing logic, explain to me, to me, this is a completely inadequate approach to a statesman's position and politi

dear colleagues, roksana andriivna, would you like to answer, are we going to continue?ove on, thank you, next, dmytro oleksandrovych, mykisha bozhik, you are also here , the 21st, we take 5:2, i think you miscalculated with the 22nd, no, the fact is that there was a second there, there were four, five and five, i count quite well, i'll show you this according to the budget, one second, i'll tell you now, you took five, then we started with the sixth, and the sixth. it's just that you calculate the railway badly, petro oleksandrovych, if that's how you calculate the budget, then there was only one correction of a railway, so the 21st, please, ruslan oleksiyovych, i am definitely not bad at counting, because my first, second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh were railway, eighth, 9, 10, 11, 12 , my, after that there were four amendments, after five and now five, first, please, which one do you start with and how many amendments do you take, from the 22nd, you see, you can appoint me as the minister of finance, the efficiency will be more, let's start from the 22nd, dm

arsalana andriivna, do you need to take a break from this, please no, thank you, let's go 352 amendment, please, vyvelichkovych, as far as i understand, yes please, dear colleagues, dear colleagues, we submitted this amendment together with mykhailo bonddor, who is a veteran of the national guard, who is currently in court, according to armann cherovyvinsky, and this amendment concerns precisely the issue of national funding for the training of personnel for the national guard, i would like to once again clearly draw attention to the fact that if the budget of 24 23 and the 24th budget of the 23rd 24 years are war budgets, then it is necessary that we support the training of personnel for ours units, i would like to remind you that several new brigades of the national guard need good officers, so please support the allocation of 50.5 million additional to fund the training of personnel of the national guard, thank you. amendment 352 by bondar and velichkovich, rejected by the committee, please vote. for 32 decisions, the following 350 third amendment was not adopted. arev, please, in pr

podlasa, please, within 5 minutes rosvilan andriivna. good day, dear people. deputies, dear members of the presidium, today we are considering the draft state budget for 2024 by first reading a total of 1,620 amendments were submitted to the budget. the budget committee held a working group meeting for two days, during which we, together with the authors and the ministry of finance, discussed and looked for opportunities to take into account all the valid proposals made by the honorable people's deputies, but according to our assessment, in order to take into account the submitted proposals, in general, additional almost uah 12.5 it is impossible to take into account all these ideas and wishes in practice, because all possible receipts of ukraine, income from placement of bonds of the domestic state loan and help. partners amount to a maximum of uah 3.960 million per year, and they have already been allocated by the ministry of finance to various expenses in the draft budget, therefore, in the budget committee, we concentrated our effort

thank you raksalana andriivna, can you look at this letter and this information, i believe and trustally wanted to to see that they do not support it. maybe then as a next step they will propose to close these institutions altogether, but i hope that will not happen. because they already sent a lot of corrupt people abroad, behind bars, and some of them escaped abroad, this too, this is a freudian trick. that people 's deputies do not take part in negotiations with the international monetary fund, thank you, but can denis valeriyovych comment on this? because he is the person who conducts negotiations with the imf, come on denis valerich, i say that i will buy, sap expenses were not supported by the imf in this budget, regarding, regarding the parameters in the budgets, hear me, hear me, hear me, tell me what to budget parameters, all budget parameters. please turn on the microphone, i turned on, please, now hear, yes, so on the parameters of the budget, all the parameters of the budget, in terms of revenues, in terms of deficits, have been agreed with our international partners, the

ruslan andriivna. thank you. honcharenko's 14th amendment was rejected by the committee, please vote. for 60. the decision is not taken, then 15, buzhanskyi does not insist , krulko does not insist on any of his amendments, tistik does not insist on any of his amendments, so i understood correctly, thank you, flu does not insist on any of his amendments, yes, thank you, proschuk does not insist on the 19th amendment, babenko does not insist on the 20th don't insist, 21sha goncharenko, please, thank you, dear friends, i will continue, unfortunately , i see that the deputies are not interested, but i will continue to tell you about real life in the state, not the fictional one that you are living in now, getting your constant somewhere, having in your plans, rest, where on some other islands or somewhere else, but real life, and real life is like this, we say, this budget should be a warring country, the army is a priority, and now i will tell you about reality of our army, and she is like that, a person gives his

ruksala andriivna, would you like to explain? no. thank you. let's go further. the next amendment? nina petrovna? and who will be 285 amendment. 285 please. everyone is very afraid of nazq and naboo. and i will comment on this amendment myself, because it seems to me that we should all be here with you. independent, absolutely not to be afraid of any anti-corruption infrastructure, and when questions are raised, so as not to spread , the reduced size of the subsistence minimum of uah 2102 when calculating wages for nazk and nabu, please tell me what this is for, why you so serve the amendments and initiatives of law enforcement organs, let you be independent, in the end, think, but i yesterday, i was talking about how it was possible to increase the salary by half a billion, for example, the bureau, not the baby, but the state security service, and not pay attention to the fact that they are the same, eh, thank you, please, 285, you don’t insist, let’s go further, the next amendment, nina petrivna. come on, oleksiy, please, honcharenko, thank you, we will skip t

roksana andriivna, i praised you so much, but you see, towards the end, your nerves couldn't stand ityou are closer to motovilovits. but let's get back to work. seriously though. then i don't understand why derspetszvyazok deals with drones, i just don't understand, show me the following in their functionality such tasks, where it is prescribed, exactly why , because it is a subordinate fodorov structure, well, that is very good, but we take a state position, not a private one, so let's direct these funds to the army and the gur. thank you, dmitry oleksandrovich, 977 we vote, yes, two 976, 977, please, one, please, 977 , the authorship of razumkov and colleagues, it was rejected by the committee, please vote, for 15, the decision, not adopted, 978 do not insist, 979- and, do not insist, insist, velichkovich, please, dear colleagues, this amendment is about making changes to of the budget program, 66-41 010, ensuring the functions of the state system of special communication and information protection and i am contacting this amendment to increase the consumption fund of this service b

roxelana andriivna up to 5 minutes, please. good afternoon, dear people's deputies, dear members of the presidium, today we are considering

looking at the potential that exists, i understand that most likely it will not happen, ruksala andriivna, if possible, give an explanation why the committee did not support her, why she did not enter the committee, thank you, the position of the committee on the 132nd editor razumkov with his colleagues, the norm is in effect the law says that if...' a state-owned enterprise has not made a decision on the recalculation of dividends, then these dividends will be forcibly withdrawn from them, if we cancel these norms, then this will lead to a lack of income from the state budget, our internal resources by many billions of hryvnias, we we can't allow this, because in that , defense is financed from the dividends of state-owned enterprises? you insist on this amendment, yes , amendment 132 by razumkov and colleagues, it was rejected by the committee, please vote for 37, the decision has not been made, the next amendment, 134 the railwayman does not insist 130. the boy does not insist, and she , i'm sorry, she is partially taken into account, but he 136 zhupani does not insist, 137 gerus does

who remain in the hall to support this edit, i will put it to a vote, thank you, please, roxanne andriivnaif you want, respond to the 455th amendment, yes, if we have already discussed it many times in these four 15 minutes that we are in the hall, in order to increase expenditures on the armed forces of ukraine, it is necessary to increase the revenues of the state budget, ukrainian income paid by ukrainian tax payers, individuals and legal entities. tomorrow you will have the opportunity to support bill 1037 on the redirection of the military pdf to the state budget and it will be an opportunity to use these funds for defense needs, if we decide as the verkhovna rada i would like to redirect all vat from local budgets to the state budget, we will even be able to increase spending on the armed forces of ukraine. thank you. thank you, amendment 455, authored by the people's mokan, it was rejected by the committee, you have heard the arguments, please vote. for 22, the decision was made. next, 456, 457, 458, 459, razumkov, dmytro oleksandrovych, as colleagues rightly pointed out, stable, st

please, i am dear colleagues, dear colleagues, please, i am asking you to take your seats, roksila andriivnayou also please take a seat. and hryhoriy mykolavych, my god, i’m sorry, mother, hryhoriy mykolavych, dear colleagues, look, here are all the people’s deputies, all the heads of state enterprises, here they are always for profits, for assets and everything else, and you can add by law, so that there are still liabilities in relation to responsibility, well, listen, i understand, you understand what great specialists work there, but questions about securities, funds, property, responsibility, riskiness of business, well, believe me, they are not even discussed there, you can to take away and transfer everything, but this is simply urgent, it is still necessary to make high-quality bills and give new models, and not to exclude them, because to whom something interferes, i ask you to pay attention to this bill carefully and decide on the maintenance of this legislation initiatives, thank you. thank you, dear colleagues, let's move on, let's move on to making a decision, i ask the people's

roksalanna andriivna, please explain the position, we will vote consecutively for these four amendments. all three amendments concern the use of balances in the state road fund. you know what the government's position, which he will propose to the hall to support, is not to allocate additional funds for construction and maintenance in the 24th year. roads, direct them to defense needs. therefore, these road residues are critical for the maintenance of winter roads, during the winter period, but some of these residues are proposed to be directed to different purposes by various people's deputies. amendment 194 proposes to direct part of the balance to funds, to the state-owned enterprise maritime search and rescue service for servicing the grain corridor. 196 the amendment proposes to direct the subvention to bridges. thank you, dear colleagues, everyone understands, i hear your position. please take your seats, we are now voting, amendment 190 by salamakha, it has been taken into account by the committee. nina petrivna puts this decision to the committee for confirmation in the hall, i

rukslana andriivna, please, if you wish, this norm appeared in the budget for the first time this yeare 34. we, as the budget committee, have questions about the wording of this norm, so that there is a decision of the constitutional court , which says that the norms included in the state budget are valid for one year, while the government is under article 34, which states that it will be valid until the end of martial law. we are instructing the government to revise this part and apply it exclusively only during the period of validity of the law on the state budget, that is, until december 31, 2024 . don't insist, okay? thank you, please, next, goncharenko, please, thank you, 180. correction, this is about, this is the exclusion of the norm regarding entry into the state agrarian register information about the value of their agricultural products. friends, what is very important, this norm and this amendment is about tells us about business, in this case, about agricultural business and certain aspects of its work. we are told again in the budget that there is money for business suppo

broken, yes, the trees were broken , and there we still take out the garbage, fill it up, kateryna andriivnaleans it, but it constantly tears it down. to mourn, the dead victor is her brother. 70 years old, it was july 14, he was my owner, he is a good man, all around him the gardens are shining, that's all, i gave him... to come eat, he cooked and roasted and skinned himself, this is already the second person killed by the russian occupiers in their family, i only saw it yesterday, only in my name, catherine, take care of yourself, run away, hide, calm down, say good luck to you, that’s all , that's right, i live, he 's alone, alone, he has children here, god forbid, there were none, but i'm here, let's not torture you for a long time, let's go. oh, it's been a year and a half since my grandson was killed, i'm 23 years old, and i'm a little like, it's not like i'm crying all the time, he's persuading me, but you don't cry, but now this guy died 200 from the night flights, where a person died, and here we see, nearby on the same street, children are playing, in fact they are the owners, firs